Blaming A Mental Health Issue For An Act Of Terrorism Takes Away From Genuine Mental Health Issues.

Image result for SUV terror attack in Melbourne

Since the white SUV was purposefully driven through Christmas shopping crowds in one of Melbourne’s busiest streets on December 21st, there has been much speculation as to the motive behind the attack.

Almost immediately….in fact with breath taking speed, authorities deemed it an attack by a person with mental health issues…. this conclusion was made within two hours of the attack which amazed me that such a medical assessment and conclusion could be drawn in such a short space of time. Now sure this person may have had a previously diagnosed mental health issue but that doesn’t mean that this specific attack was caused by his mental health issues.

Then the media started reporting that the perpetrator of the attack, Saeed Noori, had been making rambling comments that the attack was due to the way Muslims were being mistreated. He also made comments related to Allah and also ASIO. Noori is a Muslim Australia citizen originally from Afghanistan. One of Noori’s former work colleagues spoke of his very passionate commitment to Islam. But authorities insist his Muslim faith contributed nothing to his motives for the attack. They seem supremely confident of this.

Here is the problem. There have been many so called ‘lone wolf’ attacks this year and over the last few years and all of them have been Muslim terrorists. Now a Muslim drives his SUV into a crowd of shoppers in Melbourne and the authorities are falling over themselves to tell the Australian population that it’s a mental health issue…. I wonder why all the smoke and mirrors?

Here is the second problem. I have seen many Social Media posts mocking the mental health line being fed to Australians by Authorities. I feel sad for people with a genuine mental health issue. Mental health has a stigma already attached to it in Australia and we need to be having authentic and robust conversations about it…..not using it as a smoke screen to hide what is clearly a terrorist attack. Sadly, I think that all the media and social media discussions around Noori’s apparent ‘mental health’ motives for the attack, may stop people with genuine mental health issues seeking help. And indeed isolate others that are seeking help and also seeking understanding from society.

If you feel you aren’t coping with life, or you are struggling with depression, weird thoughts or other issues, I encourage you to seek some help. There is much help out there and people willing to support you and walk with you on your journey. Don’t let this issue isolate you.

Anyway, that’s what I think.


If this Blog has been helpful, informative, or inspirational to you, please feel free to share it on Facebook or Twitter. Email Subscriptions to my blog are welcome or you can contact me through Facebook (,  Twitter (@PeterPilt) or Insta (@PeterPilt). Have a great day.

My Top Ten Most Popular Blogs Are:

Categories: Australian, Current Affairs, Islam, Judicial System, Political Commentary or Thoughts

Tags: , , , , , , ,

1 reply

  1. Pete
    Your article is well written and the points made are valid regarding genuine mental health victims in my opinion
    I was diagnosed with clinical depression in 2014 following a burn out in my role as senior pastor of our church
    I found it hard to accept that I, a reasonably healthy Aussie male,could be afflicted and bought down by this insidious sickness and face a huge battle to recover
    My journey has been horrendous at times but I have been fortunate to have a great network of people including my Wife, my GP and great friends in ministry who have encouraged and supported me through this often dark process to recovery
    Sadly there were times in the early days of my sickness where I felt as though I wanted to end my life ( Yes it got that bad) but not once did I ever want to hurt anyone else. That thought never entered my mind
    Mental illness can be a traumatic period in anyone’s life but it is a beatable sickness and it is never an excuse to injure or harm others
    Thanks for your article
    Rod Smith

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: